Netherlands restitutes two works to heir of Holocaust victim
Dutch Golden Age paintings from Dutch national collection are returned
By Pac Pobric. Web only
Published online: 17 March 2014
The Dutch minister of Culture, Jet Bussemaker, has ordered the restitution of two pictures from the national collection of the Netherlands to the heir of a Holocaust victim. The Dutch Golden Age paintings, Amsterdam Town Hall by Gerrit Berckheyde and View of a Dutch Harbour with Figures by Adam Willaerts, will be returned to the unnamed claimant, who was represented by the Toronto-based Mondex Corporation during the investigation.
The pictures belonged to the Jewish collector Sam Bernhard Levie and his wife Sara de Zwarte until they were sold in 1940. The painting by Berckheyde went to the gallery D.A. Hoogendijk & Co and the picture by Willaerts was sold through a dealer to W. A. Hofer, who bought art for Hermann Goering. An investigation by the Dutch Restitutions Committee found that Levie was likely forced to sell the paintings; in the Nazi occupation of the Netherlands, Levie and de Zwarte were deported and later killed in the Sobibór death camp in occupied Poland in May 1943.
In assessing the case, the committee grappled with whether Levie could have been categorised as an “occasional dealer” of art, which would have put greater restrictions on the claim. In 1951, a former landlord of Levie’s said that he sold art out of an office in Amsterdam. While it is clear that Levie worked as a salesman, the committee could not confirm that he traded art.
Officials were also unable to confirm whether Levie “had free control of the proceeds” from the sale of the works, in which case the claimant would be obliged to make a payment for the restitution. According to a statement released by the committee, “the situation in which Levie found himself at the time of the sales are sufficient reason for assuming there was no free control of the purchase sums”.
Clarification: Sobibór was run by the German Nazi regime, it was not a Polish death camp. We are sorry for any distress this unintentional slip may have caused.
Submit a comment
All comments are moderated. If you would like your comment to be approved, please use your real name, not a pseudonym. We ask for your email address in case we wish to contact you - it will not be
made public and we do not use it for any other purpose.
Want to write a longer comment to this article? Email firstname.lastname@example.org